It's Okay To Be Careful

Somebody said it about you recently, kindly, over lunch. "Oh, she won't, she's careful."

And you smiled and agreed, because it was true and because it was kind, and something else went past you at the same moment that you didn't stop to look at.

You wouldn't describe yourself as anxious.

You'd push back on that word if anybody used it, and you'd be right to, because it doesn't fit the woman you know yourself to be. You're not a frightened person. You're sensible. You think things through. You know what works for you and what doesn't, and you've arranged your life accordingly, the way any reasonable adult does.

Careful is a respectable word. That's exactly the difficulty with it.

Nobody has ever been taken aside and told they were being too careful. There's no intervention for it. It sits on the same shelf as prudent and sensible and realistic, which are all words we hand out as compliments, and because of that it's the only description of yourself you've never once had to examine. Every other explanation you might have offered would have invited a follow-up question. Careful closes the conversation, including the conversation you're having with yourself.

So here's the distinction, and it's worth sitting with, because it's doing more work in your life than almost anything else.

Being careful describes what you do. Being frightened describes how you feel. They're not opposites and they're not the same thing, and one of them has been standing in for the other for a while now.

Notice that you can be careful without a flicker of fear anywhere. You check the road. You read the contract. You don't lend money to that particular relative. That's judgement, applied once, to a specific case, and if the case changed you'd happily change with it. That kind of careful is a decision you keep making.

And you can also be frightened and call it being careful, and nothing about the outside of it looks any different at all. Same word, same nod from the person who asked, same easy sentence. The difference is only visible from where you're standing, and only if you look.

There's a test for it, and it's a fairly quick one. Is this a decision you're making, or is it a policy you're enforcing?

The careful person reconsiders, asks what today's occasion is, weighs it up, and can come out either way. What you might be doing instead has already decided, permanently, about a whole category of things, and now applies the ruling without rehearing the case. When you find yourself declining before you've taken in any of the details, you're not being careful. Being careful needs details.

Look at how the word spread. It started somewhere specific and reasonable, one situation you had a real reason to be wary of. Then it widened, slowly, the way these things do, until it was covering a whole area of your life.

Two weeks ago I asked you to count the "I'd better not"s. Look at that list again, if you kept it, and notice how many of them came with a version of the word attached. Careful. Sensible. Not really me. Not one for that sort of thing.

Because it has other outfits, and you'll recognise yours.

You're private, so you're not going to make a thing of yourself online. You're low key, so a room full of strangers with name badges isn't your scene. You're realistic, so you're not going to be in the photograph, and you'll take it instead, which is helpful of you.

Each of those is a respectable word doing the work of a feeling, and each describes the outside of a decision whose inside is never discussed.

Now, the reframe, and it isn't what you're braced for. I'm not going to tell you to stop being careful.

I'm going to tell you that being frightened of something is allowed, and that saying so isn't a downgrade.

You've been using "careful" because the other word sounds like an admission, like something that would lower you in your own estimation. But look at what each word gives you.

Being careful is a trait. It belongs to your character, it explains your whole life, and there's nothing to be done about a trait, which is exactly why it's so comfortable.

Being frightened of this, on this occasion, is a state. It's smaller than you are. It has an object attached to it, and the object can be looked at, and states move, while traits never do.

That's the whole trade. You give up a flattering word that permanently explains everything you no longer do, and you get back a smaller, more accurate word that only covers what's in front of you. Being accurate is worth more than being flattering here, because accuracy is the only thing you can work with.

And some of it will turn out to be real caution, properly earned. That part stays. It's been keeping you sensible and you should keep it. But it'll be a smaller part than you expect, and once you can see the edges of it you'll also see everything else that has been sheltering underneath it, dressed in the same respectable coat.

So this week, once, in private, where there's no cost to it at all. Take one thing you'd normally decline as a matter of policy and say the true sentence out loud instead of the smooth one. Not "I'd better not, I'm careful about that." Try "that frightens me a bit, and I'd rather not."

Say it and notice what your body does with it. Most women expect shame and get something else entirely, which is relief, because the accurate word takes less holding up than the respectable one ever did.

Both are allowed. You just want to know which one you've got.

When your body and your nerve have been making your decisions for you, that's the work I do in a Reset Session. If it sounds like something you'd be interested in, book a free "is hypnotherapy for me" call.

Subscribe for one essay a week.